Skip to main content

College Football Playoff expansion necessary


The regular season is near its end. Twitter has been buzzing with news on possible Big 12 expansion and the college football playoff. Following one of the most injury ridden and surprise packed seasons to date, the college football playoff committee has chosen that Clemson, Alabama, Michigan State, and Oklahoma to represent the top four in the playoff.

In a turn from the wild and whacky endings of previous years, including last year when Ohio State made a surprise entry, this year was simple. Ohio State lost to Michigan State in a nail biter near the end of the season. The loss not only paralyzed their chances of retaining Ezekiel Elliot, but also a chance at the playoff. On the last Saturday of the regular season, In a last gasp for hope, Ohio State beat Michigan handily. Ohio State had made a case that they were the better team, but received no condolences.

As a neutral viewer, I argue that the one loss Ohio State team deserved a chance. Not only were the defending national champions riding a great motivating wave toward the playoff, but also they proved their dominance. The committee argued that with limited space, the champions just didn't fit. The mentality of the the playoff committee must change. College football is becoming a corrupt business looking for clients to prey on.

Even lower divisions within the NCAA have concluded toward the expanded playoff model. FCS teams play annually in the playoff to find the FCS national champion. Teams like Southern Utah and Weber state face teams like Sam Houston and Maine at the home location of the better teams first, then at a neutral site as the playoff finishes. Their current model much outdoes the FBS playoff model, and is arguably more attractive than even the eight team model.

With an eight team expansion, the changes to college football would be immense. As we wrote earlier in the year, there are multiple options to overcome the playoff complexity. The option to play an eight team playoff would allow sponsors to show their brand on a national level as each game is sponsored. The issue becomes even more complex regarding bowls when we notice that three 5-7 teams made a bowl game this year. The self-coined, "condolence Bowls" pose a threat to the college football climate as mediocre match ups and underperforming or undervalued teams play for millions of dollars. No honorable mention team should deserve such money, nor glut in the shadow of their empty meaning trophies.

College football could retain the New Years six bowls with a playoff expansion. Such an expansion would allow a more competitive field and allow players to better prepare for a professional environment, much like they do in the classroom at their respective universities. Just like any other professional, experience in their professional environment is necessary, so why not help them adapt.

Outcomes to the season would definitely be different having Ohio State, Notre Dame, Iowa, and Stanford present. As those teams prepare for bowl games, certainly underachievement is looming in their mind. With a college playoff expansion, we are only more supporting the progress of the sport, but more importantly the student athlete. Please playoff committee, do it for the sake of the game. Make a change to improve quality, and not your pocket books.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

BYU FOOTBALL: Knee Jerk Reactions

By Jacob Sorenson You could consider today an emotional day around BYU football. Legends have been made and some passed on. Specifically today, one legend will remain a legend, although passed on. With news of Ty Detmer being relieved of his duties you can't help but wonder what could have been of BYU's offense. This statement is true regardless of how well you believe the cougars performed this season. At 4-9 with a dismal offensive pedigree, BYU is simply not taking any more chances. They want something proven, perhaps something consistent. Consistency can be diluted and defined in many ways. Consistency may be 6 win seasons, it could be 8 or 9 win seasons, consistency may even just be living up character and improving. This cannot be said of this 2017 cougars team, lacking consistency both on and off the field. But is that the fault of a second year offensive coordinator with no collegiate experience other than his historic personal run? The struggle began in t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sputtery Offense? Utes' Prove Otherwise

By Jacob Sorenson Utah football writing can be difficult when the main focus is always their defense. For me, a spectator who enjoys good college football but not technically an avid supporter, I've attempted the past couple of seasons to take a very raw approach when analyzing the Utes'. I have watched, reviewed, and witnessed Utah football as an outsider with a hope of achieving balanced views. Constant questions returning to mind are; Do the Utes have the offensive presence to succeed? Do the Utes have the balance required to win the PAC12 south? Will Utah's offense have a more balanced attack and not be so predictable? Following their come from behind 31-27 win many of those questions were answered. If I did not believe or had potential doubts in the first few weeks of the season, each were for the time being satisfied. It all began in the first half when I leaned over to Shawn stating that the Utes' were too predictable. Run, Run, Run, and if necessary pass...
Post a Comment
Read more

First Loss, A Stress Relief

By Jacob Sorenson Something a real sports fan must actively look forward to is the first loss of the season. This is true in any sport and any season, but specifically in college football. How the team responds to the first loss is an indicator of their character. The stresses and pressures holding a team stationary are relieved after a loss and how they progress or digress moving forward gives professional scouts and fans reason to have hope in the present or hope for better days ahead. Improvement can even lead to national recognition and championships. But the loss is almost always a relief and a reason to settle down and play the great game of football, solely for the love of the game. I remember looking back years ago when BYU played an impressive 12-0 season. With Brandon Doman at quarterback and impressive running back Luke Staley, BYU was destined for greatness. BYU had coaching great Gary Crowton at the helm and their season was moving forward, until they met H...
Post a Comment
Read more